Elgin Realty LLC - Your Rural Property Experts Since 1958



Since 1958, Elgin Realty has been your source for rural and small town real estate. Founded by Carliss Kolker with a focus on listing and selling rural properties; his son and daughter in law, David and Gaylene Kolker took over the reigns in 1978 and became known as the Rural Property Experts. In 2004, the business was purchased and offices were expanded by another local family. During their ownership, the Elgin area had a boom of growth due to joint mission reassignments to Ft. Sill.

In March of 2017, the McDonalds purchased Elgin Realty, LLC. The rental department then began with only a few properties, with virtually no online presence initially for prospective tenants and homeowners. The property management team took off to include over 100 properties strong at the time of purchase.

Long time Elgin resident and Fletcher native, Jamie McDonald has participated in the growth of Elgin by being the primary Developer and Builder of neighborhoods like Shadow Ridge Estates, Willow Creek Estates, Wolf Creek Estates and Apple Creek Estates Part3B. Jamie’s business partner and wife, Debbie McDonald was born at RACH on Ft Sill, raised in Lawton and transplanted in 2002 to Elgin. With a strong background in Business Development, Marketing and Social Media Advertising, she is also a Graduate of the Real Estate Institute (GRI), current Managing Broker and was an active realtor at Elgin Realty LLC at the time of purchase.

This powerhouse partnership with leadership abilities, strengths, backgrounds and experience make Elgin Realty, LLC your source for all of your real estate needs. The services offered by Elgin Realty LLC include Listing, Selling, Rentals and Property Management for any type of real property to include residential, commercial and farm & ranch properties, new construction and market analysis consultation. Elgin Realty has a wide market area – marketing properties in Comanche County, Caddo County, Cotton County, Grady County, Kiowa County and Stephens County to include the towns of Elgin, Fletcher, Apache, Cyril, Lawton, Snyder, Sterling, Rush Springs, Walters, Cache, Duncan, Marlow, Medicine Park and numerous subdivisions and rural housing developments. With our knowledge and expertise of the ever changing real estate market in Southwest Oklahoma, Elgin Realty LLC is the only name you need to know when buying, selling or renting any type of Real Estate. Please give us a call at 580-492-4260 and let us go to work for you.


With 11 Realtors in the office working under an experienced licensed broker, all of our staff members are high caliber professionals with extensive experience and knowledge about our local real estate market. Our agents come from diverse backgrounds but all are dedicated to providing the highest quality service to our clients. Meet our Realtors!

Office Amenities

Our office is fully equipped with an integrated network of computer and communication systems. We have instant access to the regional Multiple Listing Service, Public Record Searches, and many other tools and services that our agents use to better serve you. In addition to our Realtors and Broker, we have a full-time administrative professional/office manager, Diane Flood, she keeps everything rolling smoothly.

Photo of the Elgin Realty offices

Certifications and Recognitions

  • Member – Lawton Board of Realtors
  • Member – Oklahoma Association of Realtors
  • Member – National Association of Realtors
  • Board of Directors – Lawton Board of Realtors
Print Friendly, PDF & Email